The Ick built a lot of buzz as an Instagram recent follow tracker. But with over 100,000 App Store reviews comes a lot of feedback — and not all of it is glowing. If you're trying to decide between Radarrr and The Ick (or just looking for a The Ick alternative), here's an honest breakdown.
Feature Comparison
| Feature | Radarrr | The Ick |
|---|---|---|
| See recent follows | Yes | Yes |
| Push notifications | Yes | Yes |
| Works on iOS | Yes | Yes |
| Works on Android | Yes | Yes |
| Real-time updates | Yes | Delayed (hourly) |
| Free tier | Yes | Limited |
| Native app | Yes | Yes |
Where The Ick Falls Short
The Ick has a strong brand and good marketing, but real user reviews point to some consistent issues.
Updates aren't truly real-time. The Ick checks profiles on an hourly schedule. If someone follows and unfollows within the same hour, you'll never see it. Users have noted the app doesn't refresh until you manually trigger it from the search bar — push notifications can lag significantly behind actual activity.
Subscription cancellation policy. Multiple App Store reviews flag that cancelling a subscription ends access immediately — not at the end of the billing period. For a $12/month subscription, that's a meaningful frustration.
Multiple competing domains. The Ick operates across theick.io and theick.ai — which can create confusion about which is the real product and which version you're actually downloading.
Where Radarrr Wins
Radarrr was built as a native iOS and Android app from the ground up — not a web tool retrofitted for mobile. That means faster performance, a better notification system, and a more reliable tracking experience.
Radarrr also offers a genuine free tier so you can test the core functionality before committing. No credit card, no trial countdown.
Who Should Use Which
Use Radarrr if: you want real-time notifications, a clean native app experience, and a free way to get started without immediately hitting a paywall.
Use The Ick if: you're already subscribed and it's working for you, or you prefer the web-based interface for desktop access.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is there a better app than The Ick for tracking Instagram recent follows? Radarrr is a strong alternative to The Ick — it offers real-time follow tracking, push notifications, and a free tier, with native iOS and Android apps.
Is Radarrr free? The Ick isn't. Radarrr has a free tier that lets you track recent follows without a subscription. The Ick requires a subscription to access its core features.
Does Radarrr work the same as theick.io? Yes — Radarrr tracks recent follows on public and private Instagram profiles and sends push notifications when new activity is detected, the same core function as The Ick.
What is theick.io? theick.io is one of the domains operated by The Ick, an Instagram recent follow tracker. Radarrr is a direct alternative available on iOS and Android.
Ready to try a The Ick alternative? Download Radarrr — free to get started.